Meet In The Middle

I have often been referred to as impulsive, extreme and intense.  Sometimes your greatest strengths are also your greatest weaknesses, right?

Well this time my extreme-ness took me from one end of the spectrum to the other before I landed somewhere in the middle.  No, I’m not talking about politics or religion, I’m talking about deodorant.

In my quest to embrace more natural products, I decided to ditch my long-time reliable anti-perspirant:  The Dove 5-pack from Costco.  Somewhere I had heard that anti-perspirants had been linked to breast cancer.  However, after investigating that claim more, I found that the correlation is actually rather slim, according to the National Cancer Institute.  They said for the most part, it’s just a rumor.  Yet, on the other hand, The Mommypotamus and Passionate Homemaking articles claim that common anti-perspirant ingredients such as aluminum, talc and parabens have in fact been linked to cancer, Alzheimer’s and other health issues.


So, what to believe???

Well, this is where I stop scouring the web and resort to my own common sense reasoning.

Erin’s brain:  So, God designed my body.  He built in a natural cooling system so that my body would have a way to self-regulate it’s temperature.  Therefore, I should try to interfere as little as possible, while still finding a way to feel civilized.   

In high school, I’m pretty sure anti-perspirant was a necessity- at least for social reasons.  With teenage hormones raging, my body had a hobby of sweating!  But as I hit my twenties, I think my hormones settled down, as did my sweat glands.  I kept wearing anti-perspirants because that’s what I’d always worn even though I probably didn’t need as much sweat protection as I had before.

Jon and I took a trip to Walmart on Saturday in search of deodorant.  Not deodorant plus anti-perspirant – JUST deodorant.  I was shocked!  Other than two scents of Tom’s natural deodorant, there was absolutely no regular deodorant for women!  There were a bunch of options for men, but none for women.  I guess they make what we demand.

I was in search of plain ‘ol deodorant because, like I said, my extreme-ness lead me to run out and buy a tube of Tom’s Natural deodorant a couple weeks ago.  After three days of wearing that stuff I couldn’t take any more.  My underarms constantly felt sticky and it gave me some kind of rash either from an ingredient or just from the constant sticky traction when I moved my arms around.  Not to mention, I had to apply the stuff three times per day – and even after all that fuss, my husband still disapproved of of my new, more “natural” (AKA: gross) scent.

So all-natural deodorant was a complete fail, but the option of a regular chemically-scented deodorant seemed like it might be a happy medium!  I could still smell and feel fresh without using some of the potentially harmful chemicals used in anti-perspirants that can be absorbed into the skin.

After much sniffing in the Walmart deodorant aisle, I came across one men’s deodorant that didn’t smell manly at all. In fact, according to the marketing it smells like “Palm Trees, Sunshine & Freedom!”  Wow, all that in a deodorant?!

The scent actually is rather lovely and in my opinion, it’s not too overpowering.  So far I really like it!

I haven’t done any extensive research on the ingredients of this Old Spice deodorant yet, so I can’t say if all the ingredients would be considered “good.”  Right now I’m simply shooting for “better than I had,” – which I think this is.  At first glance the ingredient comparison seems promising.

Here are the ingredients in the Old Spice Fiji Anti-Perspirant & Deodorant:

Aluminum zirconium trichlorohydrex gly 18% w/w, cyclopentasiloxane, stearyl alcohol, C12-15 alkyl benzoate, PPG-14 butyl ether, hydrogenated castor oil, petrolatum, talc, phenyl trimethicone, fragrance/parfum, cyclodextrin, mineral oil/huile minérale, behenyl alcohol

Compared to the Old Spice Fiji Deodorant:

Dipropylene Glycol, Water, Propylene Glycol, Sodium Stearate, Fragrance, PPG 3 Myristyl Ether, Tetrasodium EDTA, Blue 1

So maybe one day I’ll give all-natural deodorant another chance and I’ll try making the homemade stuff.  But for now, I’m fine with Fiji.


UPDATE: As of 2012 I have actually converted to a completely natural deodorant option.  You can simply try rubbing some coconut oil under your arms followed by some baking soda or you can make your own homemade chemical-free deodorant.  


6 thoughts on “Meet In The Middle

  1. I’ve had really good luck at Whole Foods finding “natural” deoderant that didn’t leave me smelling gross. Specifically they have one from a brand called “Earth Sciences” (I know, sounds like an 8th grade science class name) called Mint Rosemary that does an amazing job. They also have a lichen plant one, which has natural bacteria killers in there to kill the bad smells.

    Anyways- good luck!!

  2. So funny! We enjoyed this article so much:) don’t waste your time or money on Tom’s toothpaste…nasty nasty teeth! Only Tom’s shoes…different maker of course have won my approval.

  3. Pingback: Saying No to B.O.! | Anchor Wife

  4. Pingback: Finally Settled On A Homemade Deodorant | World At The Wayside

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s